Medical References to the Use of Methotrexate as an Abortifacient
------------------------------------------------------------------------------- MEDICAL REFERENCES to the use of Methotrexate as an abortifacient (July, 1994) -------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: Entries 1 and 3 refer to the same article.
1. Creinin, M. D. and P. D. Darney. 1993. Methotrexate and misoprostol for early abortion. Contraception 48:339-348.
KEYWORDS : medical abortion; methotrexate; misoprostol; --hCG; vaginal ultrasound; Abortion; Pregnancy; gestation; Prostaglandin;
NOTES : Methotrexate is cytotoxic to trophoblast and, in low doses, has minimal side effects. It is used to treat both gestational trophoblastic neoplasia and ectopic pregnancy. The cytotoxic effects of methotrexate on intrauterine trophoblast should be equivalent. To test this hypothesis, ten pregnant women, < 8 weeks' gestation were treated with methotrexate 50 mg/m2 intramuscularly followed 3 days later by misoprostol, a prostaglandin E1 analogue. The first 4 patients received misoprostol 600 ug orally; none aborted soon after the misoprostol. Two patients aborted 25 and 26 days after the methotrexate injection and two elected a suction abortion after 14 days (one by choice and one because the pregnancy was still viable). The last 6 patients received misoprostol 800 ug vaginally and aborted within 3- 8 hours. One patient had an incomplete abortion requiring a suction curettage 34 days after the misoprostol. Vaginal bleeding for these 6 patients lasted an average of 29 +/- 11 days (range, 12-42 days). No methotrexate side effects were observed. Vaginal misoprostol (800 ug) was significantly more effective (p = 0.005) than oral misoprostol (600 ug) in effecting abortion after intramuscular methotrexate. AUTHOR ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2. Buckshee, K. and A. J. Dhond. 1992. A new nonsurgical technique for termination of intrauterine pregnancy associated with large multiple uterine leiomyomas. Int. J. Gynecol. Obstet. 37:297-299.
Keywords : abortion; Methotrexate; Intrauterine pregnancy; Leiomyoma; pregnancy; Techniques; termination; ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 3. Creinin, M. D. and P. D. Darney. 1993. Methotrexate and misoprostol for early abortion. Contraception 48:339-348.
Keywords : Methotrexate; misoprostol; Early abortion; abortion; Medical abortion; _-hCG; vaginal ultrasound; pregnancy; gestation; prostaglandin; trophoblast; low dose; side effects; ectopic; ectopic pregnancy; women; first; injection; curettage; oral;
Notes : Methotrexate is cytotoxic to trophoblast and, in low doses, has minimal side effects. It is used to treat both gestational trophoblastic neoplasia and ectopic pregnancy. The cytotoxic effects of methotrexate on intrauterine trophoblast should be equivalent. To test this hypothesis, ten pregnant women, < 8 weeks' gestation were treated with methotrexate 50 mg/m2 intramuscularly followed 3 days later by misoprostol, a prostaglandin E1 analogue. The first 4 patients received misoprostol 600 ug orally; none aborted soon after the misoprostol. Two patients aborted 25 and 26 days after the methotrexate injection and two elected a suction abortion after 14 days (one by choice and one because the pregnancy was still viable). The last 6 patients received misoprostol 800 ug vaginally and aborted within 3- 8 hours. One patient had an incomplete abortion requiring a suction curettage 34 days after the misoprostol. Vaginal bleeding for these 6 patients lasted an average of 29 +/- 11 days (range, 12-42 days). No methotrexate side effects were observed. Vaginal misoprostol (800 ug) was significantly more effective (p = 0.005) than oral misoprostol (600 ug) in effecting abortion after intramuscular methotrexate. AUTHOR ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4. Creinin, M. D. 1993. Methotrexate for abortion at 42 days gestation. Contraception 48:519-525.
KEYWORDS : Methotrexate; abortion; gestation; Medical abortion; _-hCG; vaginal ultrasound; pregnancy; trophoblast; low dose; side effects; ectopic; ectopic pregnancy; early pregnancy; prostaglandin; women; injection; first; Intrauterine pregnancy;
NOTES : Methotrexate is cytotoxic to trophoblast and, in low doses, has minimal side effects. It is used to treat gestational trophoblastic neoplasia and ectopic pregnancy and has recently been shown to have similar effects on intrauterine trophoblast. A prior study suggested that methotrexate may successfully cause abortion of an early pregnancy without prostaglandin. To test this hypothesis, ten pregnant women at = 42 days gestation were treated with methotrexate 50 mg/m(2) intramuscularly. Vaginal bleeding started 24 +/- 10 (mean +/- standard deviation) days after the injection and lasted 10 +/- 3 days. Methotrexate side effects occurred in 4 patients and were limited to the first 4 days after the injection. Methotrexate alone appears sufficient to abort a very early intrauterine pregnancy. AUTHOR ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5. Wiebe, E. R. 1994. Methotrexate and misoprostol used in abortions. Can. Med. Assoc. J. 150:1381-1382.
Keywords : Methotrexate; misoprostol; abortions; abortion;
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Life Communications - Volume 3, No. 23 November, 1993 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 3) No Need To Wait for RU-486
Recent research at the University of California, San Francisco has shown that a combination of two drugs already legal in the US induces "safe" at-home abortions. Dr. Mitchell Creinin and Dr. Philip Darney administered the anti-cancer drug methotrexate (destabilizing the uterine lining) followed by the ulcer medicine misoprostol (causing uterine contractions) to ten pregnant women, and succeeded in killing eight of the unborn children. Excited about these results (soon to appear in the journal _Contraception_), the University has started testing the procedure on more pregnant women (and unborn children). +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Credits: | | 3 - From an AP article in the [Pittsburgh] North Hills News Record, October | | 23, 1993, p. A3. | +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Life Communications - Volume 4, No. 10 July, 1994 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2) California Experiment Successful with Another Chemical Savior
In November and December in Tustin, California, nine women volunteered to participate in an experiment by Dr. William Moss: Each woman was less than eight-weeks pregnant, and was injected in the buttock with a drug called methotrexate, a cancer-fighting drug common in chemotherapy because it kills fast-growing cells. Several days later, an artificial hormone called misoprostol was placed in the vagina. It makes the uterus contract and expel what remains of the pregnancy. Moss reported that several women complained of bad cramps, and that all the pregnancies were terminated, with no serious apparent side effects.
A feminist group raised objections to doctors (like Moss) using women as guinea pigs for their experiments. A spokesman for the U.S. Food and Drug Administration commented that what Moss is doing is permissible, yet the California Medical Board has refrained from judgment. Evidently, some doctors have been using methotrexate for several years to end particularly dangerous early pregnancies - such as ectopic pregnancies, backed up by a 1991 study published in _Obstetrics & Gynecology_ which concluded that methotrexate is "safe and effective and preserves reproductive potential," and claimed a success rate of 96.7%. For comparison, surgical abortions are successful in killing the developing child about 99% of the time.
A 21-year-old woman, who asked her name be withheld to protect her privacy, had her abortion this way. "It's more natural," she said. "You (get) your pills, and it's done with. It's a good plan for people who are afraid to go through surgery and general anesthesia."
Thus pregnancy is again reduced to the level of yet another disease: the obviously `natural' thing to do is to go to the doctor, `take your pills' and be `done with' it. Somehow this view seems to forget a certain small someone. +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Credits: | | 2 - From a May 94 article by Teri Sforza from the _Orange County Register_, | | Santa Ana, California. Many thanks to Reader Dr. Fred Worth | +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
------------------------------------------------------------------------------- This resource file is made available by the editors and contributors to _The ProLife News_, which is a a free, twice-monthly email publication. To receive a sample copy or to subscribe, or to receive a list of all of the available Pro Life resource files available in the ProLife News Archives, please send a email message to the editor: .
In all cases, except where explicitly stated, one should assume that the copyright to this file is owned by the author and/or sponsoring organization. Copying of this material is free for non-commercial use, provided that the contents (including this notice) remain intact. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------
